Learning, Innovation & Tech

Bombs & Breakthroughs

Singapore Math Demystified! Part 4: Bringing Singapore Math To Your School

CJW, June 6, 2010 6:26 PM


" . . .this deep understanding of elementary math seems to be lacking
in many U.S. teachers. I know because I was one of them
before I began this journey
       and I am still learning . . ."
                                                               --Bill Jackson

ED. Note: Math-phobia is one of the more challenging issues for our students and for this country's educational make-up and there is much to learn from other leading countries such as Singapore.

This is the final installment of the 4-part series "Singapore Math Demystified!" from The Daily Riff, guest posted by Bill Jackson, Math Helping Teacher, Scarsdale, NY Public Schools, one of the highest performing districts in the country, due to the remarkable interest expressed by parents and schools.  We are delighted that Bill is sharing his wealth of knowledge, self-initiative and fascinating journey from Japan to Germany, discovering and pursuing Singapore Math.
Links to all four parts below. 

How To Make Singapore Math Happen In Your School

Tips For Implementation
Part 4 of 4

By Bill Jackson

I have used Singapore math extensively in two markedly different school environments: an inner city school in Paterson, New Jersey and the affluent suburb of Scarsdale, New York. These experiences, as well as the many public, private, and charter schools I have worked with all over the country, have taught me that all students can learn mathematics in powerful ways through Singapore math. There are three factors, however, that should be considered carefully by schools that are thinking of using Singapore math: (1) students' levels of readiness, (2) teacher preparation, and (3) parental support. I believe that Singapore math can be successful at any school if these three areas are addressed adequately.

Student Readiness

It is important to consider students' current state of learning when implementing Singapore math. This is because the level of mathematical rigor in Singapore math is higher than in most U.S. math programs. Since fewer topics are taught each year for mastery, previously learned topics are generally seen only in the context of higher level mathematics, not repeated year to year as in typical overstuffed U.S. math textbooks. This focused and concentrated mastery approach allows students to move to increasingly higher-level mathematical content each year.

Although Singapore math textbooks are more rigorous, this rigor is not initially apparent. In first grade, it may seem like Singapore math is actually easier than typical U.S. math programs. This is because most of the time is devoted to building strong number sense - the foundation upon which future mathematical knowledge is built. By around the third grade this increase in rigor begins to become apparent and by fifth grade Singapore math textbooks are approximately one to two years ahead of U.S. math programs. Also, problem-solving strategies such as bar modeling are developed gradually across the grades. So if fourth or fifth grade students who have never had Singapore math before are thrown into the program, they may struggle because they lack the prior knowledge and strategies they need to be successful.

Depending on students' levels of readiness, it may not be wise to implement Singapore math in every grade all at once. One possibility is to implement it in kindergarten through first or second grade the first year and then add one grade level each subsequent year. Another is to give students the previous years' material (e.g. give third grade students the second grade textbook). Since Singapore math is more rigorous anyway and the earlier concepts and strategies are so important, students will not lose out by learning the previous year's content.

That being said, Scarsdale implemented Singapore math in all grades from kindergarten to fifth grade at the appropriate grade levels (e.g. fifth graders using the fifth grade books) for the following reasons. (1) Scarsdale students were already doing well academically. (2) Teachers used Singapore math material from previous grades to supplement and fill in the gaps in students' learning. (3) Some parents may not have been happy knowing their child was using a lower grade textbook. And (4), even with the difficulties and challenges of using Singapore math in the higher grades, the benefits outweighed the drawbacks.

Since student readiness is such an important issue, some people may be wondering if children should be grouped homogeneously according to ability levels. I have seen that this can be effective in some situations (e.g. special education classes). But in most cases I am against ability grouping because I think the heterogeneous classroom is a richer environment for problem-based learning. As students solve problems using different methods from simple to complex and discuss the advantages and disadvantages of their various solution methods, children can learn from each other. This rich and diverse problem-based classroom environment can bring all students to high levels. (To find out more about problem-based lessons, please see Part Two.) Of course this requires training in order for teachers to teach this way effectively.

Teacher Considerations

Most American elementary teachers have little formal mathematics training in college and several studies have shown how the level of teachers' mathematical content knowledge affects the learning of their students. This does not mean that teachers necessarily have to understand high-level mathematics such as calculus in order to teach elementary mathematics. They do have to understand elementary mathematics in depth, however, and this deep understanding of elementary math seems to be lacking in many U.S. teachers. I know because I was one of them before I began this journey and I am still learning (see Part One for details).

One important area to focus professional development on then is improving teachers' mathematical content knowledge. Furthermore, teachers need to combine a solid understanding of mathematics with good pedagogy (teaching methods), including knowledge of the methodologies and strategies used in Singapore math. This deep knowledge of both content and teaching necessary to help children understand mathematics well is what educational psychologist Lee Shulman called pedagogical content knowledge.

In my experience, teachers can acquire the pedagogical content knowledge necessary to teach Singapore math effectively in three ways:
1) learning collaboratively from one another,
2) learning from knowledgeable others, and
3) self-learning.

Learning From One Another

When I first began using Singapore math in Paterson, NJ in 2000, there were no Singapore math trainers available in the U.S. One of the ways the teachers at our school learned how to improve our practice was through lesson study. In lesson study, teachers collaborate in small groups to study materials, plan a lesson, teach it to students with colleagues observing, and discuss the lesson afterward with the group. Often an outside knowledgeable other such as a university professor, math coach, or supervisor is invited to add final comments and suggestions for further improvement. Japanese teachers have used lesson study for many years to improve their teaching, and it has contributed to the high level of math teaching seen in Japanese classrooms. In Scarsdale, many groups of teachers have gone through the lesson study process and can testify to its effectiveness in improving their teaching and understanding of mathematics.

Learning From Knowledgeable Others

Another way to help teachers is through the support of knowledgeable others such as university mathematicians or math educators, school-based or district-wide math coaches or support staff, and Singapore math trainers. In Scarsdale, I am one of three full-time "Math Helping Teachers" working with classroom teachers in five elementary schools to conduct workshops, meet together to plan and study mathematical content, teach demonstration lessons, and conduct lesson study. We have also brought in experts such as Banhar Yeap, Makoto Yoshida and Catherine Lewis to offer courses on Singapore math and lesson study that teachers can take for salary credit or stipend through the Scarsdale Teachers Institute.

Some people may be wondering if all this training and professional support requires large amounts of money. Well, yes and no. Of course some money will have to be spent initially to provide workshops and training to teachers, just as you would have to do with any new program. I would recommend, however, that schools partner with organizations that can provide support. In Paterson we were fortunate to have the support of the Gabriella and Paul Rosenbaum Foundation, Research for Better Schools, William Paterson University, the Lesson Study Research Group, the Greenwich Japanese School, and others. I would advise schools to look around and develop partnerships with local universities, educational foundations and other organizations. Also, lesson study costs comparatively little and some districts are even able to do it at no cost with some creative scheduling.


One of the best ways to learn how to teach Singapore math is just by teaching it. Since many Singaporean primary school teachers do not have a four-year college degree, Primary Math textbooks were designed by Singapore's Ministry of Education so that teachers can acquire the knowledge they need by teaching the program. If teachers carefully study the textbooks, teachersí guides and other material, they can also learn a lot. There are several good resources available to help them in this endeavor.

Parental Support

In order for Singapore math to be successful you will obviously need parental support. Parents need to understand what Singapore math is as well as what it is not. Unfortunately, some attempts to adopt Singapore math have been derailed by the so-called "Math Wars" between those who advocate teaching for conceptual understanding and those who advocate procedural and skills proficiency. As I stated in my previous posts, Singapore math doesn't take sides in this war.  Both are important.

In order to deescalate the rhetoric, schools and school districts need to educate parents and explain to them how Singapore math will help their children as well as the supports that will be offered to both students and teachers to make sure they do well. The Scarsdale schools made and continue to make a diligent and persistent effort to educate parents through parent nights, parent coffees, and other venues where parents can learn about the program and even solve problems using bar models. Parents are mostly interested in how they can help their children. Teachers can help them by addressing their concerns and sharing ideas, games, resources and web sites that they can use to support their children at home.


Given all these considerations, some might be wondering whether it makes sense for schools to take the bold step of using Singapore math. I guess it depends on how far we are willing to go and what risks we are willing to take for the sake of our children and the future of our great nation. Mark Twain said, "Twenty years from now you will be more disappointed by the things you didn't do than by the ones you did do. So throw off the bowlines. Sail away from the safe harbor. Catch the trade winds in your sails. Explore. Dream. Discover."

Well, that's the end of our time together, at least for now. I hope you have enjoyed reading this blog and that it has helped to "demystify" Singapore math for you.

Keep exploring, dreaming and discovering!

Bill Jackson
Math Helping Teacher
Scarsdale Public Schools

Part 1:  How I Became Interested in Singapore Math

Part 2:    Can Solving Problems Unravel Our Fear Of Math?
               The Singapore Math Program philosophy - Problem-based, concrete-pictorial-   abstract approach

Part 3:    Singapore Math:  Is This the Most Visual Math?      Bar-Modeling
Part 4:     How To Bring Singapore Math to Your School

Check out the recent Bill Jackson:
   "Travel Journal To Singapore"  Education:  Changing Modes

"Travel Journal - Japan"  Teacher Professional Development. Learning & Teaching Techniques


| Post a Comment

Mr. Jackson and all of the school district teachers/staff at the Scarsdale district,

Bravo! I am a Hong Kong American-Chinese with 5th graders in arguably one of the best public schools in the area. Yet it seems I am the only one seeing their math level is at least 2-3 years behind the the rest of the world. I am dripping with envy with what you have done with raising the math ability (and love of math!) of the students. Keep up the good work! May be we will be ever so lucky to have you visit our school district some day!


I know that Hong Kong students consistently score among the highest in the world in international mathematics comparisons like TIMSS. I also have been told that Hong Kong textbooks are quite similar to Singaporean textbooks and I have seen videotapes of Hong Kong mathematics lessons that were very engaging. As you may know there are many ethnic Chinese in Singapore.


What an amazing pioneer you are Mr. Jackson! My daughter is in a private school in Greenwich, CT that uses those awful textbooks that are 400-500 pages thick. Plain and simple, the math teachers here cannot teach. My daughter spent her 8th grade year doing algebra 1 with a teacher who should have been fired long ago! Due to tenure, they won't get rid of her. My daughter had to endure C's and D's; and when she asked for tutoring, they gave her the very same teacher who could not teach. She was rude and obnoxious on top of it. I cannot tell you how it ate at my daughter's self-esteem. Up to 8th grade, she had done well in math, and upon leaving algrebra 1, she was so disheartened and didn't want to tackle geometry and trig in 9th grade. Along came her magnificent math teacher this year, who was kind and understanding and scolded them in a positive way saying he never wanted to hear that they were "dumb" (teacher's words from last year) and couldn't do math. He was so encouraging. He talked about the TIMMS study and suggested to the administration that they should take a look at Singapore math since so many students were struggling. He even suggested having special kinds of math classes (i.e. math for students interested in the arts; math for historians, etc.). However, the school flat out rejected any changes. My daughter is petrified of going into Algebra 2 next year especially since the teachers are awful from what we've gleaned. This wonderful teacher is leaving (can you blame him?), because he cannot change the system and is extremely frustrated. My daughter and I will be going to Asia this summer (passing through Singapore), and I wondered if there are any programs we could/should purchase while there, and if it would help her for next year. Or would studying this method cause confusion if she has to learn the American way? It's very sad, particularly that we are paying so much in private tuition, that there isn't a math system that would be more fun and interesting for the students. It's truly heartbreaking. She did very well this year with her wonderful math teacher, but none of the other teachers teach like he does (he told us that). Bless you for these wonderful articles!


I am sorry to hear about your daughter's all too familiar experience in math class. I think one of the problems is the unfocused nature of the textbooks and curriculum but another is how we train teachers in the US. I am writing a blog that will appear soon on this web site on how teachers improve continually throughout their careers in Japan through a process called lesson study. We need to support and train teachers in better ways if we are to develop consistency and see improvement in mathematics teaching in this country. As far as materials to help your daughter, I do not think that Singapore math textbooks would confuse your daughter because although there are differences in approach, focus, rigor, etc., mathematics is still mathematics all over the world. I am not sure what programs available in Singapore I could recommend as I am not familiar with all that is available there but there are Singaporean and other excellent materials available at www.singaporemath.com. Tell your daughter to please not become discouraged. She and all students can learn mathematics in powerful ways with the right instruction!


Hallo Sir,
Greetings. I am writing from Kenya. I am a Kenya woman very pasionate about mathematics, especially in changing attitude towards the subject. After many years of research on the same, we recently registered a foundation to push forward that agenda at a continental level.
Our programs include professional development trainings for teachers and we are set to have ground breaking workshops in Kenya and Dar this August. I have just learnt that my key facilitator/trainer who i was expecting from Michigan is not able to make it coz of unavoidable circumstances. I am desperately looking for a facilitator, from that end. We will be able to take care of the travel arrangements and give a honorarium. Please let me know if you can help. Thanks


You might be interested in a response from Richard Rusczyk, he of Art of Problem Solving fame and trainer of top math competitors. After a presentation wherein he basically shredded conventional middle and high school math teaching (complaining that it was insufficiently focused on problem solving and discrete mathematics and too preoccupied with calculus) he was asked if Art of Problem Solving had anything for elementary school kids. In a couple of years, he said. But what about NOW? was the desperate follow-up question. To that he replied, "Singapore Math. If it were my kids I'd use Singapore Math."

You might also mention the enhancement materials that are scaled to match Singapore Math and which focus on hard problems that require simple computational skills, also available from singaporemath.com.

And finally, although you didn't touch on homeschooling at all, for those of us who homeschool highly gifted kids because school doesn't serve them, Singapore Math is an ideal solution. Not just because of the texts, workbooks, and home educators' guides, but because of the excellent teacher training materials, such as Elementary Mathematics for Teachers, that accompany it.

Great series of articles, by the way.

You make some great points here. I have found that mathematicians are some of the biggest proponents of Singapore Math, perhaps because of the mathematical nature of the program (i.e. it's not a reading book about math like some U.S. textbooks) as well as the high level of rigor. I do not know much about home schooling but I know Singapore Math is popular among home-schoolers, not just those whose children are gifted but struggling ones as well. Finally, the enhancement materials you mention are very good, particularly Challenging Word Problems and Intensive Practice, both of which have non-routine problems as well as more challenging material. The teacher training materials, such as Elementary Mathematics for Teachers and Elementary Geometry for Teachers by Parker and Baldridge. Thank you for sharing your comments.

Post a Comment

Arithmetic is being able to count up to twenty without taking off your shoes.
Mickey Mouse

Passionate about our edu-nation?

RIFF it here

Follow The Daily Riff on Follow TDR on Twitter

find us on facebook


Singapore Math Demystified!

CJW, 10.01.2010

Guest Post By Scarsdale NY Teacher Bill Jackson
Can It Help Solve Our Country's Math-phobia?

Read Post | Comments

Riffing good stories


An Inconvenient Truth In Math Education: A Very Viral Video

CJW, 10.01.2010

Math Wars: 3.0The Top Viral Video  --And It Ain't a Pretty Picture For"New Math"  aka Everyday or Terc Math--With national standards in Math being introduced this week, we thought it might make sense to show one of the top videos...

Read Post | Comments

School Leadership: Jumping From Good To "Great"- Jim Collins & The Top Ten

CJW, 09.30.2010

What Jim Collins, Best-Selling Author of "Good To Great" and A School Principal Have To Say About What Leaders Students & Teachers Need Now

Read Post | Comments

Is Math Art? "A Mathematician's Lament"

CJW, 09.30.2010

Teacher Paul Lockhart Ph.D Reveals: Math Education, Teachers, Testing, Curriculum-Dream or Nightmare
Every Parent & Educator Should Check Out This Book Excerpt

Read Post | Comments

Colbert to Parents: Keep Fear Alive

CJW, 09.30.2010

"The More You No" Video: Banning Books & the March on Washington DC in October

Read Post | Comments

Would You Hire Your Own Kids? 7 Skills Schools Should Be Teaching Them

CJW, 09.30.2010

Tony Wagner, Former HS teacher, Principal & Co-Director At Harvard School Of Education Posts. "The Ability To Ask The Right Questions Is The Single Most Important Skill."

Read Post | Comments

"The Many Teachers In Our Lives"

CJW, 09.29.2010

"Five Writers Share Their Memories" Of Fellow Soldiers, Parents, Spouses & Friends
Opinion From The Los Angeles Times

Read Post | Comments

Students Need Different Things: "We Are All Part Of The Puzzle"

CJW, 09.29.2010

Guest Post By California English High School Teacher & Author Jim Burke

Read Post | Comments

Why Our Kids Don't Get Math

CJW, 09.28.2010

Joseph Ganem, Ph.D. gives us three surprising reasons why and how it may change our idea of "rigor".

Read Post | Comments