Wit & Wisdom

Game Changers & Tales of Triumph and Woe

Put Yourself In Our Shoes: "What Would You Do?"

CJW, August 6, 2010 5:37 PM


Put Yourself In Our Shoes - What Would You Do? 
The Question General Motors Asks New Hires  

Here's the scene:
A small group of us were talking about the complexity of hiring a school leader (in this case a private school).   One would think it would be at least easier than dealing with the regulations attached to a public school search.  The group was evenly split between business and academia (higher education) in terms of experience.

The discussion included goals, qualifications, traits and strategies, before we moved on to more anecdotal experiences, mainly tactical.  We found ourselves desiring a different outcome when it came to a discussion about what questions are worth asking during an interview when hiring, and it went like this:  

Business person:   "I had a mentor who taught me always to ask a strange question like "Are you a lucky person?" since it inevitably threw off the "good interviewees" from their prepared Q&A speak.   We always value "how quickly they could think on their feet."

Academic:  "How interesting - I would say it is almost opposite in academia.   Quick response may indicate impulsivity.   Slow and deliberate implies a deeper thought process."

He continued by saying in an ironic tone:  "Pondering is valued."

(Laughter from all)  (Does anyone remember the movie "Being There" with Peter Sellers?) 

Academic:  "By the way, what is the right answer to the question (about being a lucky person)?"

Business person:  "There is no right answer . . ."


So when we came upon this interview with Susan Docherty, "who leads the United States sales, service and marketing team at General Motors", in The New York Times, it was time to ask:

Are schools creating an environment where students can enter the real world without a complete behavioral and expectation disconnect?

We know, we can hear it now, "education is not just about work readiness."    Yet we spend the major portion of our time when young in school.  We then spend the major portion of our post-school life with work.  Isn't work an integral part of who we are?  Work is not some  separate "silo" apart from good citizenry, self-fulfillment and our ability to make a difference in this world.

And, yes, we get that education is not like business.  It's "messier" because it involves kids and so many moving parts.  Business also is very messy and involves a cast of characters and challenges in its own right.  Try being at GM right now.

We've been talking to many business owners of late who have lamented the lack of initiative and curiosity from interns, new or potential hires...and, on the flip side, the same concerns are being voiced from professors in higher education.  Instead of thinking of it as laziness or lack of interest coming from students, we hear another consistent theme:  fear of making mistakes, the need to be told what and how to do  something step-by-step, doing just what is needed and no more.   Does it stem from our testing culture?  Our over-programmed kids?  Are they being taught that things are not worth doing unless it is attached to a grade or a diploma of some sort?  

Back to Ms. Docherty.   Below are a few excerpts from the interview by Adam Bryant with link here to full interview, where she shares her strategy for leadership, how not to come off as bossy (and why it's more important for a woman), and why she likes to sit in different chairs in meetings.

Do school leaders think this way?  Do teachers teach for this kind of thinking?  Are our schools set up for this type of behavior?  Do we value innovation and different ideas?  Do we like ideas that come from the student to the teacher instead of the other way around?  Just asking. 

"Q. How do you hire?

A.  . . .   make sure that when I'm looking at people for my team, it's not just what's on their résumé -- their strengths or weaknesses or what they've accomplished -- but it's the way they think. I can learn twice as much, twice as quickly, if I've got people who think differently than I do around the table.

Q. What feedback have you heard about yourself through the years?

A. I will tell you that 9 times out of 10, people say that I'm impatient. However, I think in the environment that we're in right now, coming out of bankruptcy, that has become a strength.

Q. When you're gathering comments about someone, what phrases do you like to hear, and which ones scare you off?

A. The ones that scare me? If I hear the person uses sarcasm negatively, or is a constant second-guesser. The things that excite me would be team player, innovative thinker and a willingness to take risks.

Q. So you've got your input and you've decided to interview someone for a job. What are you asking them?

A. One of the first questions I ask is, "Can you describe a decision that you made, or a situation that you were involved in that was a failure?" And I don't need to know how they got to the failure. But I need to know what they did about it.  How they handled that is the best illustration of whether or not they're an innovative thinker and are comfortable taking some risk.

Q. Any other acid-test question?

A. I always ask people, "If you could be in my shoes today, what would be the top three things you'd do?"  When most people prepare for an interview, they're very focused on their prior experiences and examples of what they've done. . ... It demonstrates to me how they think on their feet without being prepared.

Sometimes I get answers back that are very in-the-moment, tactical answers. Sometimes I get very leader-like questions about vision, about things that are way beyond stuff that we're currently thinking about. I love that question, because it's very telling about how people think. And then there are other people who give a very balanced view, with thoughts on the short-, medium- and long-term. So I get a real quick read on strategic versus tactical thinking.

Q. What other leadership lessons have you learned?

A. Whether you have a really small team or a really big team, communication needs to be at the forefront. It needs to be simple . . . Because everybody listens at different levels, and everybody comes to the table with a different perspective and a different experience. And the same words mean different things to different people.

On some very key things, people need to internalize it, and they need to own it.

. . .And I think being disruptive, and not always being predictable, is healthy."

Previously published by The Daily Riff 2/10

If you liked this story, you may also like The Daily Riff's:



Post a Comment

Inspiration is for amateurs. The rest of us just show up and get to work. Because everything grows out of work. You do something and it kicks open a door.
Chuck Close, artist, 'Charlie Rose', Creative Brain

Passionate about our edu-nation?

RIFF it here

Follow The Daily Riff on Follow TDR on Twitter

find us on facebook

Leading the way book cover.jpg

The Chinese Curse. Is America Next?

CJW, 11.18.2010

Is America Leaving Behind What Asia Wants? : Controversial Book & Video

Read Post | Comments

Riffing good stories


Khan Academy: World's Free Virtual Private Tutoring Lessons In Math & Science

CJW, 11.18.2010

How Kids Can Get Private Tutoring With Ten-Minute Sessions On Targeted Subjects Ranging From Basic Math To Advanced Calculus; Parents Can Check Out Finance,Too.

Read Post | Comments

Jeff Bridges takes on childhood hunger

CJW, 11.18.2010

MSNBC's "Morning Joe" clip with Mika Brzezinski and Joe Scarborough: "Obesity is just the flip side of this hunger issue"

Read Post | Comments
rural schoolhouse.jpg

A "small story" with big implications: education, rural communities and design

CJW, 11.18.2010

A "Small Story" with Big Implications - Education, Rural Communities and Design - "We need to be better citizens in our own backyard"

Read Post | Comments

A Connected Teacher: Priceless

CJW, 11.17.2010

The Connected Classroom: Ideas For Teaching With A Real-Time Global Perspective

Read Post | Comments

Crossing the Math Chasm

CJW, 11.17.2010

"the silver bullet for making math education work" : Conrad Wolfram video

Read Post | Comments

Does Investing in the Early Years Lead to Students' Success?

CJW, 11.16.2010

Early education (ages 0-5), brain development, parental involvement, community collaboration and bridging the achievement gap: Los Angeles Panel Discussion

Read Post | Comments

Daniel Radcliffe Sings the Elements

CJW, 11.14.2010

Radcliffe sings the periodic table of elements on the Graham Norton show with Colin Farrell, Rihanna...humor video

Read Post | Comments
visionsof math.jpg

Visions of Mathematics

CJW, 11.12.2010

Ben Daley of High Tech High Outlines a Revolutionary Approach to Math

Read Post | Comments