Book Riff

Good Ones

Is This Book Exposing Cracks In Schools Of Education (Teacher Colleges)?

CJW, September 23, 2010 9:15 AM


Previously published 4/26/10

Is "Teach Like A Champion" Hitting An Unexpected Nerve?

by C.J. Westerberg 

Was I missing something?  Jay Mathews over at The Washington Post today called Teach Like A Champion  an "explosive book" and until I read his entire post, I didn't quite understand what the combustion was all about . . . understanding it as a book with an intense focus on technique over theory, as the March The New York Times Magazine cover story, "Building A Better Teacher" conveyed. 

The Daily Riff covered it HERE with "Building a Better Teacher".
But Mathews' angle this time illustrates  how and why it is so difficult for schools of education to embrace new thinking:

"Many education schools are taking steps in this direction, particularly with video. But Lemov provides more detail than many of them are comfortable with. One professor told me education students can't be motivated to embrace such methods until they are in a rough classroom fighting to survive."

Really?   Let me get this straight:
teachers-in-training have a hard time "embracing" these methods until it gets more real, and these will be the same teachers who will get frustrated by Michael in 8th grade Algebra class because he, too,  "can't be motivated"  unless he is in a survival mode?

 " . . .The ed schools give them (students at ed schools) theory and practice in digestible form, and send them off. If they don't get a good mentor teacher, they are in trouble."

Wow, such low expectations for teachers-in-training.  Or, are Schools of Ed taking the path of least resistance?

"Teachers creating new evaluation systems in D.C. and Montgomery share some of Lemov's (the book's author) impatience. What he is offering is hard, and easy to dismiss it as too minimal, too routinized, too basic. Whether it succeeds depends on how many of the restless new generation of teachers are willing to work that hard, when some experts say they don't need it and the pay isn't that good anyway. . ."

I really hope this isn't the case.  Because if the learning of additional teaching techniques is "too much work" then we're all in trouble.  I highly doubt every teacher will use every technique with equal weight or turn into robotrons.
What do other professionals strive to do... doctors, lawyers, sales, management?  The good ones try to add as many quills to their quivers as they can, to use when needed.  Some are never used.   Will adding new techniques help good teachers get better?  Yes.  Will they make a terrible teacher better who really doesn't like kids or teaching?  No.  Do we really think every teacher will use all 49 in one class on a given day?  C'mon.  (Personally, I've been through technique/video training throughout my career and some can be . . . how to say it, singular in intent and contrived to make a point?  But still,  I felt if a session gave one great take-away, it was time well spent, and it was  .  . .) 

Does learning "technique" eliminate the heart and soul of education?  Here's an example:  I love to play tennis and know that learning a certain technique can make me better.  Significantly and astoundingly better.  Other techniques, for me, are left on the shelf - just didn't make the difference/irrelevant/too weird/etc.   Do I play tennis for technique?  You gotta be kidding.  Do I love tennis even more since I'm better/more empowered?  You bet. 

Let's do a "what if".  What if a few techniques make all the difference in the world for a teacher in terms of class management and connecting to students so that he/she spends far more time on the things that are important.  (We would expect teachers to have content knowledge, yet many (self-admittedly) spend far too much time on classroom "management" where valuable time is lost, or not knowing techniques for differentiation within a class.)  

 "But as Lemov puts it, methods that work as well as these make the school day go much more quickly and smoothly, and justify the high hopes of this new group of educators."

Yay or Nay on this line of thinking?
If you want even more on this debate, check out The New York Times today Here for three completely different points-of-view on this subject in Letters  - short - we promise.....

And for more on the apprenticeship value for teachers, click here.

Two minute videos below:


1 Comment

| Post a Comment

Thats a wonderful blog post! I am so pleased you decided to talk about it.

Post a Comment



Project-Based Learning at the University Level

CJ Westerberg, 02.25.2017

Biology Students meet Film Majors. . . and vice versaWhere Serendipity HappensBy C.J. Westerberg (NEW POST)While listening to my local Hawaii Public Radio w/Beth Ann Kozlovich - specifically Town Hall show, the question of whether higher education is embracing cross-disciplinary,...

Read Post | Comments

Would You Hire Your Own Kids? 7 Skills Schools Should Be Teaching Them

CJ Westerberg, 01.11.2017

Tony Wagner, Former HS teacher, Principal & Co-Director At Harvard School Of Education Posts. "The Ability To Ask The Right Questions Is The Single Most Important Skill."

Read Post | Comments

Cultivating the Entrepreneurial Learner

CJ Westerberg, 11.06.2016

"We dedicate this book to the parents of children who are growing up in the digital age. We hope our contribution will illuminate the strange and wondrous learning styles of the next generation." John Seely Brown

Read Post | Comments

Are we creating innovators? 22 Insights

CJ Westerberg, 11.04.2016

C.J. Westerberg dissects Tony Wagner's "Creating Innovators" Video Trailer

Read Post | Comments

Shaping Serendipity for Learning: Conversations with John Seely Brown

CJ Westerberg, 10.22.2016

"Conventional wisdom holds that different people learn in different ways. Something is missing from that idea, however, so we offer a corollary: Different people, when presented with exactly the same information in exactly the same way, will learn different things." - John Seely Brown

Read Post | Comments

Late Bloomers (Guess what? You didn't peak in high school ;)

CJ Westerberg, 06.22.2016

How 2012 Nobel Prize Winner Dissed by High School Biology Teacher - CJ Westerberg post

Read Post | Comments

Seven Questions: Is your child a recipe-follower or a real learner?

CJ Westerberg, 10.22.2015

John Holt: The Seven Ways to Picture a Student's Understanding - - - by CJ Westerberg

Read Post | Comments
Sparks of Genius. Thirteen Thinking Tools.jpg

How the Arts Prepare for a Life's Work in any Discipline

CJ Westerberg, 07.24.2015

Including Science, Technology, Engineering and Math

Read Post | Comments

Chinese Super Schools?

CJ Westerberg, 11.09.2014

"No one, after 12 years of Chinese education, has any chance to receive a Nobel prize, even if he or she went to Harvard, Yale, Oxford or Cambridge for college . . ." Yong Zhao

Read Post | Comments

Author John Green: Teenagers Think the Big Questions in Life Matter

SMW, 06.02.2014

Why Do We Give Them Short-Shrift? The Teen Whisperer: How the author of "The Fault in Our Stars" built an ardent army of fans

Read Post | Comments
Thumbnail image for Make Just One Change.jpg

Teaching Students to Ask Their Own Questions

CJ Westerberg, 02.22.2014

Now, here were college grads looking for jobs, and not recognizing that showing curiosity and asking engaging questions could show MORE about WHO they were than reciting some resume paragraph to interviewers in a random interview. -C.J. Westerberg

Read Post | Comments

It's Personal: How a Parent Perspective Changes Everything

SMW, 12.09.2013

"For every problem that technology solves, it sort of creates a new one."

Read Post | Comments

American Teacher: responding to students, environments and conditions

SMW, 12.05.2013

"There are very few schools that purposefully try to create lines and connections between different fields. The way most high schools are set up, you're in history class, and then the bell rings; then you go to science class, and then the bell rings."

Read Post | Comments

Video: What is the link between "design-thinking" and creativity?

SMW, 11.03.2013

Creative Confidence: Must-Watch Interview on Charlie Rose

Read Post | Comments

Choke: Test-taking - - - a different way to look at test-prep?

CJ Westerberg, 10.28.2013

"Most students will not find a steady diet of test-prep drills and worksheets to be particularly meaningful, and accordingly, they will not put forth optimal learning effort."

Read Post | Comments

Today's WOW Story: Yong Zhao's "Be Careful What You Wish For"

SMW, 10.03.2013

Flipping Standardized Testing on its Ear

Read Post | Comments

Is Math Art? Dream or Nightmare?

CJ Westerberg, 09.29.2013

"A Mathematician's Lament"
Every parent & educator should check out this book excerpt

Read Post | Comments

How 7 Principles Of Baseball Can Help Transform How Teachers Teach

CJ Westerberg, 07.16.2013

How to Teach so Kids Can Think and Learn - by Harvard's David Perkins

Read Post | Comments

The Education Horse Story

CJ Westerberg, 07.15.2013

15 Ways to Ride a Dead Horse

Read Post | Comments