Learning, Innovation & Tech

Bombs & Breakthroughs

Washington Post: Top High School Prevents Curiosity in Learning

CJW, October 19, 2010 8:22 PM

monkeysee.Jaymathews.Washingtonpost.jpg

"Is that the best way to encourage learning? Are we so stuck on managing classroom competition that we can't let students explore libraries, or the Internet,
and make connections between the textbook and the real world?"
 --Jay Mathews, The Washington Post

"Curiosity Discouraged at Competitive High School"
 
(Ed. Note:  This struck me as a bell-ringer because it just didn't feel like the typical Jay Mathews post.  Learning, curiosity?  In any event, veddy interesting.  - C.J. Westerberg)

Excerpts from The Washington Post's education columnist, Jay Mathews' Class Struggle column titled, "Curiosity discouraged at competitive high school":

Westfield High School in Fairfax County is one of the largest and most competitive public schools in America. It is not unusual that 180 sophomores enrolled in Advanced Placement World History this year, more students than most U.S. high schools have taking AP courses of any kind.

What did surprise some Westfield students and their parents was a sheet titled "Expectations of Integrity" included in the materials handed out by the three
AP World History teachers. Their number one rule discouraged random
outbreaks of curiosity:

"You are only allowed to use your OWN knowledge, your OWN class notes, class handouts, your OWN class homework, or The Earth and Its Peoples textbook to complete assignments and assessments UNLESS specifically informed
otherwise by your instructor.
. . ."

. . . .That was not all. Students could not use anything they found on the Internet. They were not permitted even to discuss their assignments with friends, classmates, neighbors, parents, relatives or siblings. . .

And Mathews' conclusion:

If the teachers are worried about cheating, there are Web sites and applications to catch plagiarists. I wish there were also an app to unleash curiosity, which in this class is locked up for the rest of the school year.

Read full article here.   It appears that the educational system has created such a curious lot of students that our best action is offense, or do we just call it offensive?   So much for "lighting a fire" to inspire curiosity which is the precursor to life-long learning.  Even if these actions were in response to cheating, as expressed by one of the commentators to Mathews' post below, it is a no win either way:

My guess is that there is- or has been in the recent past - a serious problem with cheating. And that gets at another problem with AP; students are so intent on making themselves "look good" - which is derived from parental pressure(s) and the endless promotion of AP as "better" by such writers as Jay Mathews - that they sign up for all the AP courses they can, find themselves stressed and time-constrained, and they look to cut corners. It isn't really about learning.  

Guess we've come a long way in the learning arena, folks.

For two very timely videos related to this post:

 "Sir Ken Robinson - Changing the Education Paradigm"

"Race to Nowhere: A must-watch documentary - Are we creating a generation of unprepared high achievers?"      A different look at AP courses:  Video clip




###

Post a Comment

As I grow older, I pay less attention to what men say. I just watch what they do.
Andrew Carnegie

Passionate about our edu-nation?

RIFF it here

Follow The Daily Riff on Follow TDR on Twitter

find us on facebook

Mona.Lisa.Pretty.jpg

"Pretty" Blown Away

CJW, 10.27.2010

Not just for parents of girls: Poetry Slam video

Read Post | Comments

Riffing good stories

lifelab.learning.alankay.jpg

Life as a Learning Lab

CJW, 10.26.2010

" . . .we've spent hours and hours discussing how we can help students follow their interests and passions, and also help students learn powerful ideas and develop as systematic thinkers." Mitchell Resnick on Alan Kay, Squeak and Scratch

Read Post | Comments
Apple.johnsculley.jpg

John Sculley on Genius

CJW, 10.25.2010

Former CEO of Apple riffs about Steve Jobs, what makes the best innovators & the nature of genius in this essay tribute to mentor - his "Oxford Don" - Alan Kay

Read Post | Comments
Quincy-Jones.jpg

Quincy Jones: a three sixty human being

CJW, 10.25.2010

Legendary Quincy Jones riffs about music, technology, math, creativity and yes, even parenting in this essay tribute to friend Alan Kay

Read Post | Comments
global.tech.jpg

Myths & Opportunities: Technology - Part 2

CJW, 10.22.2010

By Alan November: Six Creative Ways Our Kids Can Become "Contributors"

Read Post | Comments
snail.effort.jpg

The Unintended Consequences of Grading "Effort"

CJW, 10.22.2010

"Even when I try really hard, I'm still dumb." Grading effort is a precarious endeavor that teachers need to think long and hard about before . . .

Read Post | Comments
compass.jpg

Alan November On Learning & Technology

CJW, 10.21.2010

By Alan November - The Video - Learning & Motivation Are Tied To Students Being "Contributors" In School, The Classroom & The Outside World

Read Post | Comments
Thumbnail image for nightmare.math.jpg

Kindergarten Test-Prep Nightmare!

CJW, 10.20.2010

Is test-prep ruining early education in America?
Check out the alternative "Math Salon" approach

Read Post | Comments
monkeysee.Jaymathews.Washingtonpost.jpg

Washington Post: Top High School Prevents Curiosity in Learning

CJW, 10.19.2010

"Is that the best way to encourage learning? Are we so stuck on managing classroom competition that we can't let students explore libraries, or the Internet, and make connections between the textbook and the real world?" --Jay Mathews, The Washington Post

Read Post | Comments