Video

Through the Education Lens

Is Learning a Sport?

CJ Westerberg, June 25, 2014 12:02 PM

scoreboard.learning.jpg

(Ed. Note: This week, The Atlantic posts Why Kids Care More About Achievement than Helping Others, as if we are surprised - how schools and parents may be contributing to this development.   Am we really surprised?  A classic post below.)

"Students should not go to school to win -
 students should go to school to learn."


Is Learning a Sport?
 Video Below
by Chris Wejr 

This week the topic of awards surfaced again on Twitter.  As a result, Vancouver Sun reporter Janet Steffenhagen posted part of my blog post,  "Death of An Awards Ceremony",  that described the decision parents and staff made to significantly alter the way we recognize kids.  Instead of our year-end awards ceremony, we decided to have a year-end honouring ceremony along with recognizing individuals throughout the year for their individual strengths and passions.  Awards ceremonies are zero-sum, meaning that although they create a few winners, they create many losers.

Through Twitter and Janet's post, a common opposing argument to ending awards is that if we get rid of awards we:

" . . . should we end all games in a tie? . . ."

" . . . might as well get rid of championships . . ."

"  . . . .might as well eliminate sports teams, too."

" . . .are we not preparing our kids for the competitive environment
       that is the 'real world'? . . . "


Sport is huge in my life.  My friends, players and teammates will tell you: I am one of the most competitive players and coaches in the rink and on the court.  I have spent the majority of my adult life coaching volleyball, basketball, and track.  During this time, although the main goal was never to just win but more about the journey and process, I was involved in sports that resulted in a winner and a loser.  I am not against competition (there are still fun, healthy competitive games in schools and classrooms); I am against awards ceremonies and events that place emphasis on the result rather than on the learning.

The key difference between sport and learning is that you CHOOSE to play sports and you go in with the knowledge that there is a winner and a loser.  Students should not go to school to win -  students should go to school to learn.  Students should not go to school to compete for some award at the end of the year; students should go to school to collaborate and learn from teachers and peers.  We rob our children of intrinsic motivation by continually offering extrinsic motivators.

Also, for those who say, "if we get rid of awards, we might as well get rid of test scores and grades and entrance exams"; I say: ABSOLUTELY, these also do not promote learning.  I will, however, leave this conversation for another post.

To many people, unfortunately, learning does seem to be a sport.  For those people who believe this, here are some questions to consider:

  • When/why did learning in school become this zero-sum activity that creates winners and losers?
  • Are certain areas of school favoured over others?
  • How do you award the top learner?  How is one learner better than another?
  • How much do politics play into awards in schools?
  • Is it more about the parents wanting their kids to have awards or is it about the kids needing awards?
  • Who has taught these kids that awards are important?
  • What stays with you for life - the intrinsic motivation of knowing that one can learn or the extrinsic motivation of trophies, certificates and prizes?
  • Is one child's strength more/less valuable than another child's strength?
  • Do we give out awards for top academic child in the family?  If an argument is that we "need to prepare students for the competitive real world", why do most not do this within their own families?  (I am still awaiting to get to this awful "competitive real-world" that people keep warning me about -).
  • If, according to Deci and Ryan, extrinsic motivators take away from intrinsic motivation, and not only will the non-award winners be harmed but also the winners, then why would we continue with our awards tradition?

Obviously, I am being a little cynical with these questions but hopefully it makes people reflect on the flaws in having learning viewed as a sport with winners and losers determined at awards ceremonies.

If all students can excel in something and all students can learn, how can there be losers?  The answer: hand out awards for learning and make learning a sport.

"We need to stop celebrating the best,
and start celebrating personal best"
Video below
Rick Lavoie

We need to work to see the value and strength in EVERY child, EVERY day.  If we resort to recognizing only a select few at the end of the year, we are failing the majority of our students.  Let's tap into our students' interests and work to honour our students for the strengths and passions within each one of them.

Learning is NOT a sport, it is a journey; an enjoyable journey that never ends.

###
Posted The Daily Riff February 2011
above post slightly modified for clarity


Chris Wejr is school principal at Kent Elementary School in British Columbia.  He has spent his career working
with students as a high school physical education, math, and science teacher, an intermediate teacher, an
elementary vice-principal, as well as a high school volleyball, rugby, track, and basketball coach.
You can find
him at The Wejr Board.

###

Editor's Note:  Check out the videos below.  The first is a mash-up of the (3) videos that follow.
All well-worth the visit.  - C.J. Westerberg

 

 Related posts by The Daily Riff:

Are We Wrong about Motivation?  Daniel Pink thinks so.

Two Schools:  Which one builds the better bully?  by Ira David Socol

The Day I Abolished Grading by Joe Bower

Death of an Awards Ceremony by Chris Wejr

How to Create Non-readers:  Reflections on Motivation, Learning and Sharing Power in the Classroom  by Alfie Kohn




  • I totally agree with this article. "We need to work to see the value and strength in EVERY child, EVERY
    day. " This will not only improve knowledge but also the strength of the child to grab more knowledge and learn more to make them able to stand in front of other students equally at the same level.

blog comments powered by Disqus

PREVIOUS Video

bug.Peter-Drucker.Jim-Collins.jpg

Ten To-Do's for Young People to Consider

12.16.2014 | #1 - Build a "Personal Board of Directors" Watch Now | Comments

brain.mouse.cage.homework.jpg

Mind Overload! from Technology & "Societal Exhaustion"

12.16.2014 | Mindfulness: "I've seen it transform classrooms . . . " Watch Now | Comments

nature.abstract.jpg

EcoTherapy: "You're gonna look at some trees" - Video :)

12.12.2014 | Truth in Humor ---- It's come to this, folks Watch Now | Comments

dog.bored.disengaged.Big-picture-learning.jpg

"It's Disengagement, Stupid"

12.11.2014 | The 10 Essential Rules for Engagement Watch Now | Comments

thorns.Koretz.jpg

21st Century Skills: A "thorny problem" in the classroom

12.08.2014 | . . . .most high schools' science "experiments" are really "demonstrations," because they are "rigged" for the right answer, thereby disqualifying them as true experiments where outcomes are unknown. Watch Now | Comments

Colbert2.jpg

Weekend Funnies: How to inspire kids to be "Not a scientist"

11.08.2014 | Man-Made Climate Change?The Colbert Report  - VideoThe "I'm not a scientist" riff starts at the 2:50 mark.  The entire video (under 5 minutes)  is well worth the watch: The Colbert ReportGet More: Colbert Report Full Episodes,The Colbert Report on Facebook,Video... Watch Now | Comments

Colbert2.jpg

Stephen Colbert's Sound Advice: How To Ace The SAT's

11.05.2014 | Tip #1: "Spend A Lot Of Money . . ." Watch Now | Comments

generationLostGlobe2.jpg

TEENS -- A LOST GENERATION?

11.04.2014 | Now almost 16 million views - "brilliant" video - under two minutes Watch Now | Comments

student.dunce-cap.jpg

Being Pegged, Late Bloomers and Effort

10.30.2014 | How 2012 Nobel Prize Winner Dissed by His High School Biology Teacher Watch Now | Comments

Stephen does Common Core Math

06.30.2014 | Video in case you missed it - Math! Watch Now | Comments

There is No Education Without the Arts

06.29.2014 | "We're not talking about making sure that everybody has private music lessons," Watch Now | Comments

College Professors Read Their Student Reviews

06.29.2014 |  Quick Video Below Gotta love the college profs for sharing -... Watch Now | Comments

scoreboard.learning.jpg

Is Learning a Sport?

06.25.2014 | Maybe . . . Why Kids Care More About Achievement than Helping Others Watch Now | Comments

Ivory Tower: The Movie

06.11.2014 | A documentary about higher education that "questions its cost and value" . . . Watch Now | Comments

Author John Green: Teenagers Think the Big Questions in Life Matter

06.02.2014 | Why Do We Give Them Short-Shrift? The Teen Whisperer: How the author of "The Fault in Our Stars" built an ardent army of fans Watch Now | Comments

College Debt and Banks: It's called "Skim"

05.28.2014 | aka. No-brainer money for bankers; debt for students for brain-credentials Watch Now | Comments

Sparks of Genius. Thirteen Thinking Tools.jpg

How the Arts Prepare for a Life's Work in any Discipline

05.23.2014 | Including Science, Technology, Engineering and Math Watch Now | Comments

Want smart & different kind of brilliant? Check out John Oliver

05.13.2014 | Video - Humor His Climate Change segment with Bill Nye and "the deniers" is just that. Watch Now | Comments

How Chicago's BAM (Becoming a Man) program works

05.01.2014 | Teaching students to identify thought patterns that contribute to depression & anxiety so they can work to replace them with healthier patterns. . . Watch Now | Comments

Finland. Finnishflag.BobCompton.jpg

The Finland Phenomenon: Inside the World's Most Surprising School System

03.17.2014 | New update December 2, 2013 which includes Yong Zhao link and comments PLUS CNN videos Watch Now | Comments